Why a generated after misleads
Viewers read a before-and-after pair as proof: this is what happened to a real person, room or surface. An AI-made after shows a result nobody achieved, and an AI-enhanced one shows more than the product delivered. Either way the image itself is the claim, and an unsupported claim. The UK Advertising Standards Authority made the principle explicit in 2021, when it ruled against influencer ads on social media for tanning products whose images had been filtered, finding that filters exaggerating a product's effect are misleading. Generative edits are the same problem with more power.
Where the rules bite hardest
Cosmetics and skincare, weight loss, hair and teeth treatments, aesthetic procedures, cleaning products and home improvement all lean on before-and-after imagery, and all attract complaints. In the EU, cosmetic claims must meet the common criteria of Regulation (EU) No 655/2013, including truthfulness, evidential support and honesty, and the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (2005/29/EC) covers misleading commercial practices towards consumers generally. In the US, the FTC requires claims to be substantiated, and its Endorsement Guides treat a testimonial result as typical unless the ad clearly discloses what people can generally expect. Medical and weight-loss advertising carries extra sector rules in most markets.
What AI can do safely
Illustrate a mechanism in a style that nobody could mistake for a photograph: a drawn cross-section of skin, an animated diagram of how a cleaner lifts grease. Lay out and size genuine before-and-after photographs consistently across formats, without touching the subject. Show a proposed renovation or interior as a clearly labelled visualisation of a design rather than as finished work. Produce everything around the evidence, such as backgrounds, typography and the rest of the campaign, while the evidence itself stays a real, unaltered photograph.
Documenting genuine results
A genuine pair should be shot under the same light, from the same angle and distance, with the same styling and make-up, so the difference visible is the product's effect and nothing else. Keep the raw files, dates and the person's consent. Make sure the result is typical, or say plainly what results people can generally expect. Keep a record showing the photographs were not generated or altered; in Synthetic White, every asset carries a record of which model made what, which helps keep generated material apart from untouched photographs.
Updated 26 October 2026